This is a voter-driven story. After each scene is posted, a new poll will be put up so voters can collectively decide what happens next. Readers can also suggest possible scene options in the comments.
Content Warnings: BDSM Fantasy, F/f, lesdom, M/f, maledom, bondage, non-consensual, kidnapping, handcuffs, duct tape, tickling
Professor Vaugn reacted first, taking a step toward the bound and gagged Dani.
The two goons were busy holding Colleen still. One of them was keeping his gloved hand clamped tight over her mouth and the other was holding her down. The cuffs keeping her wrists and ankles together were firmly in place. Colleen squirmed, but the two of them held her still. She didn’t try to say anything, just as intent on watching Vaughn as the men.
Dani had clearly thought these people were here to save her from being punished for interrupting Colleen’s study time. Her expression was pure relief until she heard the word “targets.” Now with every step Sonia Vaughn took in her direction that relieved face shifted into confusion, then concern, and finally horror when Vaughn reached her, bent down, and unceremoniously began to grope her tits and ass.
“Mmfgough! Ssdob ih!” Dani tried to wriggle away, but Vaughn had a good grip on her. There was nothing the willowy blond could do to stop the plump woman from grasping at her breasts, feeling her up from her chest and rear to her legs, feet, stomach, and every other body part Sonia Vaughn thought worth exploring. She remained curled into a half-naked ball by all the tape Colleen had subjected her to, but the struggling she did not strained the silver material to the limit.
Both the squirming and the screaming got worse as Professor Vaughn gave her a few hard smacks at the same spot on her rear Colleen had been spanking not too long ago. Dani started muffedly begging the older woman to stop, and that begging soon shifted to laughter when the professor moved on to tickling the soles of her feet and her sides.
“Hey,” said one of the goons, the one holding Colleen’s mouth shut. “Get the gag while she’s busy.”
“Huh? Oh, right. Here you go.”
“Mmmph?”
The men shifted and moved atop Colleen’s body. Seconds later her eyes widened when she felt the grip on her mouth loosen up and leave her face—only to immediately be replaced by a wad of spongy material the man shoved through her teeth. Colleen tried to shake her head, but the man now had her in a headlock and she couldn’t stop him from putting the whole thing, whatever it was, into her mouth.
“Agh,” Colleen grunted. Then something else was shoved behind her teeth, a rubbery ball. Colleen screamed louder as she felt straps buckled tightly behind the back of her head. “Mmaaummph!”
The two men stood, pulling Colleen into a sitting position on the couch as they did. Professor Vaughn finished up with Dani at the same time and was in the process of dragging Colleen’s tall blonde roommate over to her buddies. When she was back in the living room, the professor stood up straight and looked one of the goons dead in the eye.
“I want this one too,” said Vaughn with Dani at her feet. Dani made a small whine of protest, but it was too weak and quiet for anyone to pay it any mind. At this point the bound woman was exhausted.
Colleen remained silent and observed all her captors as the two goons looked back at the university professor.
“That wasn’t the deal,” said one of the goons. He laid a hand on Colleen’s shoulder. His grip was too strong for the cuffed brunette to shake off. “You get this one, and we get anyone else in the place. Remember?”
“I don’t expect her for free.” Vaughn rolled her eyes like a teenager. “I’ll pay—with a discount mind you—for the blonde. I just think it would be a shame to split these ladies up if this is how they spend their free time.”
“Whhmm ooo uu eeagh aaay?” Asked Dani from the floor. Colleen understood it easily enough. ‘What do you mean pay?’
Dani was ignored.
“We’d get a lot more from a private buyer or an auction then we could from you.”
Colleen reeled back at the same time Dani cried out. “Aaauushuugn?!?”
“How many students have I helped you get your hands on since I started working with you?” Demanded Vaughn. “Hell, how many girls have I given you just this semester? It took me all that time to ask for just one pet. You can let me have two pets instead.”
It took everything Colleen had not to start freaking out on the couch. These men were slavers! Professor Vaughn was working with slavers! And for a long time, apparently. Long enough, and with enough victims, that Vaughn thought it was worth taking a couple of slaves of her own in exchange.
The speaking man, the one gripping Colleen’s shoulder, gave his partner a look. The other man crossed his arms. They looked back to Vaughn at the same time, and the speaker gave their answer.
“Sonia, we paid you for all those girls. This deal was separate. You can’t just change it on a whim like this.
Vaughn sighed. “Come on. You have their apartment and probably their phones. Just text some of their hot friends to come over and sell them instead!”
Apparently the implications of the situation hadn’t sunk in for Dani until now. She cried out at Vaughn’s words, “EEHLL!?”
“Yes dear, sell,” Vaughn looked down at Dani. “These nice men were going to sell you and let me have your mistress. But now I’m going to take both of you home so you can stay together. You’re welcome.”
Colleen was breathing hard now, trying to process what she had just heard. The stuff about being kidnapped and sold was horrible enough on its own, but what did Professor Vaughn mean when she called her Dani’s “mistress?” Did she think Dani let Colleen tie her up like that?
The speaking goon pinched his forehead. Everything about his body language screamed exasperation. “Arlight, fine. You can have both.”
Vaughn preened, but the surprised the other goon turned to his partner. “Seriously?”
“Yeah. Thanks to her we’ve pulled in enough merchandise off this campus that two doesn’t matter. Besides, she’s right about these sluts’ phones. We can use them to get our hands on some other girls.”
“Nnggghoooo!” Dani screamed from her space on the floor. Colleen didn’t blame her. She herself was almost hyperventilating at this point.
“I knew you’d see things my way.” Professor Vaughn bent down to give Dani a pat on the head she must have thought would be comforting in her deranged mind. At this point it was obvious that Colleen’s teacher wasn’t all there in the head. “There there, sweetie. It will be all right. Soon enough you’ll forget all about your old life. I’ll be your Mistress now. And unlike Colleen, I won’t let you get caught by anyone else. You’ll be all mine.”
“And as for you,” Vaughn directed her attention to Colleen. Her smile sent shivers down the cuffed brunette’s back. Colleen felt herself instinctively try backing away from the professor’s ravenous grin. “I’ve been itching to get my hands on you for months. Oh yes, we’re going to have so much fun together!”