Paula residence, October 31 2019, 8:15 PM





"Oh Elizabeth, I'm home! Where are you? You're supposed to be giving out candy."





Paula looked around, concerned that her girlfriend wasn't handing out candy up front. The last thing she wanted this Halloween was to be egged by upset trick or treaters.





As she got to the kitchen, she saw a red balloon with a note attached. She grabbed the note and read it.





"Dear Paula, I have Elizabeth tied up somewhere in this house. Find and free her in 15 minutes or you lose. Signed:  The Halloween bandit."





Now Paula was terrified, there was a thief in the house and had already taken Elizabeth hostage. After a second, she told herself to remain calm and to think it through. 





"Think Paula, think! If I were to tie up someone, where would I hide them? A place where she would be seen or heard. Of course, the basement!" As she rushed towards the basement, she grabbed a kitchen knife on the counter, just to be safe.





She walked quietly down the stairs, noticing that one light was on. In the light was Elizabeth, tied to a chair and cleave gagged. 





"Mmmmph, hummmmmph mmmph!" Elizabeth screamed through the gag. Paula has never seen her so worried about being tied up.





"Don't worry baby, I'll get you out of here."





"No you won't. You lost the game Paula." Paula wiped around looking for the source of the new voice.





"What are you talking about? I found her, didn't I?"





"You only completed half of the game. The other half was to free her." Paula now noticed the voice was coming from behind a curtain and started to tip toe towards it, knife in hand.





"You have lost Paula, I win" the voice says as she is in front of the curtain.





"Too bad I'm a sore loser!" She shouted as she threw the curtains open, only to reveal a recorded device.





"Wait, then where's the ban-MMMPH!!!" She screamed as she was grabbed from behind and a rag was placed over her mouth.





"That's right, I won, you lost. Now suck it up and breathe the chloroform in." The bandit said as Paula struggled. "MMMMPH!! MMMmmph. mmmmmph." Shortly, Paula tired herself out and collapsed on the floor.





"Well, she sure tired out quickly. Now to tie her up and to make away with all the valuables in this house."





"MMMMPH!!!" Elizabeth shouted in protest. The bandit just looked at her, eyes filled with lust.





"Of course, she'll be knocked out for a while, so you and I can have some quality time together."





"MMMMPH!!! MMMMPH!!!!" Elizabeth shouted even more, but her attempts were futile.





"I won't lie, I've been looking forward to this ever since I saw you. Maybe I'll even take you home with me and you can be my slave. Wouldn't you like that?"





Elizabeth shook her head and tried to scream. As the bandit closed in, Elizabeth closed her eyes in fear, dreading what comes next.











"Thunk"





As Elizabeth opens her eyes, she is surprised to see the bandit on the ground unconscious and Paula standing up holding a vase.





"That's what you get for not tying me up and for using chloroform, that stuff takes forever to kick in."





She rushed over to Elizabeth, ungagging her.





"I thought the chloroform knocked you out." She said, finally free from the gag.





"Sweety, anyone can fake being unconscious. I just held my breath and waited for her to get distracted. Thankfully, your sexy body is always a perfect distraction."





Once free, Elizabeth wanted to thank her hero with a kiss on the lips. Paula stopped her before she could land one on her.





"Before we get into that, we should take care of her first. Any ideas?"





Elizabeth thought for a second. "Payback." She said with a grin





Paula also grinned. "Payback it is."

























"Mmmph?mmmmmmmmph?" The bandit slowly came to her senses. Suddenly, she realized that she was hogtied on the floor in the basement. "MMMMPH!!!" She tried to scream, but the sponge in her mouth and the 12 layers of tape holding it in made it next to impossible for her to speak. Shortly, the basement door opened, Paula and Elizabeth both walked down the stairs.





"Oh look, she's finally awake. It's hard to believe it has already been 30 minutes since you knocked her cold."





"MMMMMMPH!!!!! MMMMMPH!!!!" She screamed at them through the gag





"Wow someone has a mouth." Paula said. "Listen, here is what's going to happen. We're going to give more candy out to trick or treaters, then we're going to call the cops on you for trying to rob us. We'll say we made a citizen's arrest and restrained you so that you wouldn't be able to escape. How does that sound?" 





"MMMMMMPPHHH!!!!"





"I'm taking that as a no. Well to bad we don't care about how you feel. Now let's give out some more candy sweetheart."





"Anything for you, my busty knight in shining armor." Elizabeth responded.





They walk up the stairs, leaving the would-be burglar bound, gagged, and helpless in the basement to suffer another hour before they call the cops.