"Are you ready for fantastic night of trick or treating!?"

Baleigh was bouncing around as usual, but on Halloween night she was extra excited. The two had planned for a quiet night in while they watched a spooky movie and handed out treats to the kids. Of course, to get into the spirit of the night, Baleigh had insisted that she and Grace dress up.

"You'll handle the door answering business, right?" Grace said as she continued her work of emptying bag after bag of candy into a large bowl.

"Of course! Leave it to me. By the way, your costume is great. You make a great witch!"

Even though she wasn't thrilled about the idea of dressing up, if Grace was going to dress up for the evening she wanted to do it right. As a witch, Grace wore a tight fitting black dress with gold accents. It had long sleeves that were tight around her upper arms, but then opened up and billowed out the rest of the way. Her legs were encased in a pair of fishnet tights, and her feet were tucked into high heeled black boots from which a pair of dark socks were seen rolled up just below her knees. Of course, her look wouldn't be complete without a hat which she wore on her head with her hair tied up in a bun and tucked inside.

In classic best friend fashion, Baleigh had decided to also go as a witch! Her costume was different though. She wore a tight fitting orange long sleeved shirt that was tucked into a very short black skirt. On her legs she wore a pair of striped orange and black tights complete with a pair of high heeled ankle boots from which a pair of thick black socks peeked out of.

Together, they were a right pair of witches ready for a night of fun! With the last bag of candy emptied into the bowl, Grace walked it over to the front door. She then returned to the living room and started to work on getting the movie on for the night.

"Do you care what we watch?" She asked Baleigh, "or should I choose?"

"Um, you pick! I'll be busy passing out candy anyway, so make sure it's something you really want to watch."

"Nightmare Before Christmas it is," said Grace as she pulled the DVD out.

*knock knock knock*

"Oooh our first guests," Baleigh said as she skipped to the front door.

"Trick or treat!" Grace could hear the excited voices of kids calling out for their treats as Baleigh giggled and remarked on their costumes.

Such was the rhythm of the night. Baleigh would sit with Grace and watch the movie until a knock was heard at the door upon which she'd launch herself off the couch, race to the front door, and hand out candy to the children. She was making constant trips for about an hour, but once it really started to get dark things slowed down a bit. The movie was nearing it's close too, and Grace was already getting tired. With the gaps between visitors getting longer and longer, Grace was about ready to call it a night.

"Hey," she said turning to Baleigh, "you about ready to call it quits?"

"One more visitor!"

"It's been about fifteen minutes since the last one. Do you really think anyone else is coming?"

"I'm sure of it! Besides, we still have a little more candy left in the bowl to give out anyway!"

"Okay, well, go ahead and just give them the rest of what's there."

"Sounds good!"

*knock knock knock*

And just like that, the last visitors of the night were at the door and for the final time Baleigh jumped off the couch and ran toward the door. Grace turned her eyes back to the TV as the movie finished up. She waited for Baleigh to come back, but after a few minutes the credits started to play and she noticed Baleigh was still not back yet.

"Hm," said Grace as she switched off the tv, "that's odd..."

Getting up from the couch she walked over to the front door to find the entryway empty and the door closed. Grace rolled her eyes. Clearly, Baleigh was playing a prank on her.

"You can come out now," she said, "we've been over this before. I don't get scared easily, so just give it up."

Carefully, Grace crept around looking to see if she could spot Baleigh hiding anywhere. Strangely enough, she was nowhere to be found. Whatever she had planned for Grace she had obviously put some thought into it! This wasn't the first time Baleigh had tried to scare Grace like this. Usually it never worked because Baleigh was rather clumsy and couldn't keep her excitement contained which gave her away, but this time she had really outdone herself!

"Alright fine," Grace said as she wandered back toward the kitchen, "I'll play your little game..."

"How about you play ours?"

Grace whipped her whole body around to find herself face to face with someone who was definitely not Baleigh! The girl was dressed in a little black dress, pattered tights, a black high heels. She wore a black witches hat on her head of jet black hair. A devious grin was painted across her face with her hands planted on her hips.

"Who the hellmmmmmmph!"

Suddenly, Grace was grabbed from behind by a second intruder! The girl in front laughed as she now lunged at Grace and scooped her legs up into the air. Grace thrashed her body around trying to get herself free, but whoever was holding her from behind had a vice-like grip, and the girl in front was plenty strong too! She was now realizing that Baleigh was most likely not playing a prank on her, but had fallen victim to these two devious intruders!

"Mmmmmmmmmmph!" Grace cried out in protest, but she was tightly hand gagged.

"Hurry, let's have her join her friend!"

"Will do!"

The voice that spoke behind Grace was clearly another female. Whoever these girls were they were strong as hell, and Grace found herself completely helpless as the two girls carried her upstairs. Pushing open the door to Grace's bedroom, the girls lugged Grace inside to where they had sequestered Baleigh earlier.

"Hyymmmph lllmmph hhrrrmmmph gggmmmph!"

Baleigh was gagged with a few strips of tape so her speech was fairly garbled, and she had been tied down to one a green footrest that Grace kept in her room. She was stretched out over it on her stomach with her hands tied together at the front. Grace could see rope looped underneath the footrest toward the other end where Baleigh's legs were. Her knees just barely kissed the floor with her feet raised up behind her just beneath her bottom. They were kept up in the air thanks to the rope that was tied between her ankles and her thighs. The girls had also taken the liberty of wrapping tape around Baleigh's hands so that they were both completely enveloped in the sticky material leaving as if she was wearing one large tape glove. It was quite the binding job and kept Baleigh nice and secure.

Oh, and to add insult to injury, Baleigh's costume was now missing. Grace really had no idea how the girls could have moved with such speed, but in the time that Baleigh had been gone, they'd managed to drag her upstairs, remove her dress, and tie her up like this. Grace would have been impressed if she wasn't so miffed. In any case, poor Baleigh was left in just her bra and tights now. They'd even removed her booties as well leaving her in the black socks she wore underneath.

"Alright, let's take care of this one too."

"Mmmmrrrrrph!" Grace tried her best to shake free of the two girls, but found herself unable to. Instead, she had her arms pulled behind her back as her wrists were lashed together with tape. In the meantime, to keep her quiet, the girl with the black hair ripped off a few strips of tape before slapping them over Grace's mouth.

"Fmmmmph ymmmmph!" Grace said as she starred daggers at the girl who only smirked in reply.

With Grace's hands taken care of, and her ability to yell removed too, the girls moved on to phase two of their operation...and it started with a pair of scissors.

"Alright, girlie...sit still!"

"Nmmmmmmmph!" Grace, who had been lowered to the floor at this point, kicked her boots legs out while the other girl continued to hold her from behind.

She had spent good money on this costume and was absolutely furious that these two lunatics would dare defile it in such a way! But sadly her efforts were in vain as the girl quickly cut the dress away from Grace's body.

"Ta-da," she said throwing it aside in dramatic fashion.

"Hmmmph! Grace huffed as she scowled up at the girl.

She was now wearing only her white bra, and fishnet tights. Her boots were still on though, but Grace figured they wouldn't be left on for much longer. She wondered what these two girls had planned for her and Baleigh. Who were they anyway?

"Nice job, Brooke. This should really teach these two lousy snoops a lesson!"

Grace's eyes grew wide. As the other girl, the one who had been holding her from behind, finally walked into view it hit her. Brooke and Natalie were their names. Natalie was the dark haired girl who Grace had seen initially, and Brooke was the other one wearing a tight red dress over a sheer long sleeved turtleneck, black nylons, and red open toed heels. She stood next to Natalie while tossing a roll of duct tape into the air.

Grace stared at them, her eyes wide with astonishment. The girls noticed the look on her face and smirked.

"What's the matter...miss us or somethin'?"

"Ggmmph!" Grace tutted back.

A few weeks ago, she and Baleigh had worked on a case involving these two, their parents, and fake college admissions. What had happened was their parents were caught bribing Ivy League schools in order to get Brooke and Natalie in, because of course they were too dumb otherwise, and it had been Baleigh and Grace that figured it out and exposed what they were doing. Turns out the girls were a tad upset and had come by to get revenge...

"It was a real shitty thing you did," Natalie said tossing her dark hair over her shoulder.

"Yeah," said Brooke adjusting her red hat that sat atop her short cut brunette hair, "things were going just fine until you two snoops decided to ruin everythin'! Now what are we supposed to do, get into college like normal people?"

Baleigh and Grace exchanged irritated looks.

"Well, we hope this teaches you a lesson not to mess with other people's lives."

"Fmmmmph ymmmph!" Grace said as she kicked her feet out just barely missed Brooke's leg.

"Why you little...fine, if you don't want to just sit there and take it, then I guess we'll have to really make the message clear for ya'!"

Bending down, Brooke unzipped Grace's boots before yanking them off and throwing them behind her. She then peeled both of Grace's long black socks off before wrapping tape around her ankles and just above her knees.

"I don't know about you, Natalie, but I don't think these flimsy little gags are going to cut it. I can still make out way too much of what they're sayin'!"

"I couldn't agree more," Brooke said as she sauntered over to Baleigh.

Scooping up one of Grace's black knee socks, Natalie whirled it around.

"Oh yes," she said, "I think this will be just right."

Out of the corner of her eye, Grace watched Natalie carefully peel off both of Baleigh's socks as she then circled around to the front of the footrest to where Baleigh's head was.

"Dnnnnmmph ymmmph dddrrrmmph!" Baleigh kicked her legs, as much as she could considering the way she was tied, and shook her head as Natalie laughed while playing with Baleigh's socks.

"My oh my," she said, "you really do have such an adorable little fighting spirit. Too bad you're a nosy bitch!"

And just like that, Natalie ripped the tape off of Baleigh's mouth who sat there for a second to recover before launching an array of insults at Natalie.

"It's not our fault you two are dumb as dirt and couldn't get into college you mother fmmmmmmmmmmmmmmph!"

But of course, Baleigh's verbal assault was cut short as Natalie crudely shoved both of Baleigh's socks straight into her open mouth.

"Fffffrrrrrmph hhhhrrrgggmph mmmmmmph!"

Baleigh sputtered and gagged as Natalie worked both of the socks into her mouth. Once they were in as far as they'd go, Natalie took the roll of tape and began to wrap layer after layer after layer of tape around Baleigh's face. She gave no mind to Baleigh's hair either, trapping it underneath the many rounds of tape. The new gag was a significant improvement on the two measly strips of tape from earlier. As Baleigh continued to holler, she was now reduced to quiet muffles thanks to the two large socks filling her mouth.

It was now Grace's turn as she fixed her gaze back on Brooke who was still twirling Baleigh's long sock around. Grace could at least breath a sigh of relief. She didn't envy Baleigh at all. Those two crew socks she was wearing were decently thick, and to have both packed in her mouth like that did not seem fun at all. On the other hand, Grace figured Brooke would probably just use her long sock as a cleave gag before wrapping tape around her head. There was no way she'd be able to fit the whole thing in her mouth...right?

Reaching up, Brooke peeled the tape from Grace's mouth who took the chance to get in one last deep breath before inevitably being reduced to breathing exclusively out of her nose.

"Any last words?"

Once again, Grace found herself rolling her eyes. These two punks sure were dramatic if nothing else...

"Well go on," she said, "just get it over with. You're too dumb to insult anyway."

Brooke furrowed her brow in anger.

"A bitter bitch until the very end," she said, "I hope tonight is a reminder for y'all to mind your own damn business!"

Before Grace could open her mouth to reply, Brooke shoved Grace's sock into her mouth.

"HMMMPH?!"

Grace's eyes grew huge as she felt Brooke jamming in more and more of the long sock. She wasn't going to cleave gag Grace at all...she was going to shove the whole sock in!

"Mmmmmmph mmmmmph!"

Grace shook her head as Brooke continued the arduous task of fitting the whole sock in. Natalie had to come over and help hold Grace still so that Brooke could finish gagging her. To Grace's astonishment, Brooke managed to basically fit the whole thing in...Grace's mouth was jam packed of course and her cheeks were bulging out, but the sock was in!

Quickly, Brooke scooped the roll of tape up and started to wind it around Grace's head as fast as she could in order to trap the sock in place. She used way more tape than was needed, but of course she did...both she and Natalie had gone overboard on everything else so far.

"Hmmmmph!"

Grace could hardly utter a sound behind her massive gag. Natalie and Brooke took the rest of the tape and finished wrapping more of it around Grace's body. They looped it above and below her chest so as to pin her arms firmly down to her side, and then like Baleigh they wrapped a bunch of tape all around her hands completely covering them.

Finally, with their work of securing the two girls complete, Natalie and Brooke stepped back to admire it all. They stood there, hands on their hips, smirks on their faces, taunting the girls.

”Fmmmmph Mmmmmph gggggmph!” Grace and Baleigh, Baleigh especially, were fuming behind their gags.

"Well then," said Brooke, "it seems like we should let our friends stew here for a bit, don't you think Natalie?"

"Oh, I think so...but wait..."

"What is it?"

Grace watched as Natalie leaned over and whispered something in Brooke's ear. A very devious smile crept across her face as she slowly nodded her head.

"Yes, that sounds perfect!"

The girls then pranced off as Baleigh and Grace mewed after them.

"Gnnnmph mmmrrrph hhmmmph!

It was only a few minutes before the girls returned, but they hadn't returned empty handed. Helping themselves to Grace's fridge they had come back holding bottles of syrup, chocolate sauce, and a can of whip cream. At first, Grace was perplexed at this, but then the more she sat and thought about it, she realized exactly what the girls had planned for her and Baleigh...

"Well, I don't know about you two, but Nat and I have been having the time of our lives this evening. I wanna thank y'all for indulgin' our harmless tricks on this fine Halloween evenin'. But, now I think it's time we moved on to the treat portion of the evenin', wouldn't you say?"

"Nmmmmph fffmmmmmmmph!"

Both Baleigh and Grace squirmed in protest, but there was nothing they could do to stop Natalie and Brooke now.

"It's hard to believe y'all could get any sweeter," Natalie said as she bent down and waved the jug of chocolate sauce in Grace's face, "but let's see if we can try, yeah?"

Popping the cap off the bottle, Natalie took it and began to gently pour it straight onto Grace's head.

"Ggggggggnnnnnmph!" She moaned and kicked her legs while the sticky chocolate sauce slowly spilled down from her head dripping onto her shoulders and sliding down her face.

Natalie laughed as she continued to dump the chocolate sauce all over Grace, moving now from her head down to her chest as she squirted it all over. Grace shivered with goosebumps as the cold sauce was drizzled over her bare skin, her white bra now ruined with chocolate stains all over. Natalie really took her time with things, even going so far as to squeeze sauce on Grace's legs over her tights.

Baleigh was being given the same treatment but by Brooke who had taken a bottle of syrup and was currently drenching Baleigh in the sticky viscous substance. She made sure to really get it into Baleigh's hair before moving on to the rest of her body covering as much of it as she could in the sticky liquid.

To top it all off, they took the can of whipped cream and between Grace and Baleigh completely emptied it as they gave each girl generous dollops onto their heads, and other exposed areas. Grace had her chest covered in whipped cream, and while Baleigh's chest was currently planted in the footrest, the girls made sure to cover her exposed nylon clad rear with a healthy layer of the whipped cream instead.

Of course, while Baleigh and Grace sat there stewing behind their sock packed mouths, hating every moment of what had just happened, Brooke and Natalie were as jovial as ever. They laughed and snickered as they drenched each girl, paying no mind to the massive mess they were making.

"I think that does it," said Brooke tossing the empty bottle of whipped cream to the ground, "like we said...this better teach you both a lesson! Don't mess with us. You got it?"

"Yeah," parroted Natalie as she draped her arm around Brooke's shoulder.

"This whole scene has me feeling a bit hungry," said Brooke, "you girls don't mind if we help ourselves to a nice meal downstairs, do you? Great, thanks! Come on, Natalie."

And just like that the two girls skipped off downstairs leaving Baleigh and Grace to soak in their sticky predicament.

"Fffffmph!" Grace snorted as she did her best to tilt her head and keep the chocolate sauce out of her eyes.

"Llllmmmmph!" Baleigh rocked her body back and forth atop the footrest.

What an absolute mess! Sure, being drenched in sugary sauce was one thing, but she was more upset at the lack of respect either girl paid to the carpet! The stuff had gotten everywhere and was going to be just a nightmare to clean. All Baleigh and Grace needed to do was take a nice hot shower, but it would take much more to clean up the floors!

The anger she felt over this was motivation for Grace to start wiggling her way across the floor toward her desk. With her hands totally enveloped in tape it was going to be a real long shot if she was going to get herself free. Plus, Baleigh wouldn't be much help considering she was thoroughly tied down to the footrest. Still, Grace was going to try as hard as she could to get free before Natalie and Brooke finished whatever it was they were doing downstairs. Payback was coming alright...and she'd make sure of it!

Natalie stretched her arms and yawned before going back to scrolling on her phone. After raiding Grace's fridge, she and Brooke had helped themselves to quite the feast before plopping down on the couch and scrolling their social medias. Finally, Natalie got up and announced that she was using the restroom. Taking her phone with her, she sat in there for a good while before eventually returning to the couch.

Upon her return she noticed Brooke had gotten up to.

"Hm," said Natalie as she paid it no mind and plopped back down, "maybe she's gone upstairs to check on things."

If it wasn't for her mindless scrolling, perhaps Natalie would have been more prepared for the sneak attack that was about to be launched on her. As it was though, she had no idea and was totally unprepared making her the perfect target.

"Surprise, bitch!"

"Hey what thmmmmph!" Natalie threw her arms up dropping her phone in the process as a pair of hands grabbed her from behind, sticky hands at that...

"Hmmmmmmmmph gggggnmmmph!"

She hollered through the hand that covered her mouth as she watched none other than Baleigh Sommers, her blonde hair still matted with syrup, jump in front of her with a grin of triumph on her face.

"You two really aren't all that bright," she said.

"Nmmmmmmmmmph!"

"Uh, Baleigh," Grace said as she struggled to keep a tight grip on Natalie, "a little help here?"

"Sorry, on it."

Taking a roll of tape, Baleigh wound it around Natalie's ankles and knees. She and Grace then rolled her over and shoved her down into the couch face first as they pulled her arms behind her back and wrapped her wrists together with tape.

"Nice work," said Grace.

"Of course," Baleigh said practically beaming.

Grace always wondered how she could skate through life so unbothered. Still covered in syrup, Baleigh was as cheery as ever. It was charming really, and Grace couldn't help but smile.

"Fffffffmmmmmph!"

With her head buried in the couch, Natalie wasn't able to make much of a sound, but Baleigh and Grace knew they should finish the job. Lifting her up, they carried her out to the entryway where they had subdued Brooke.

"Nmmmmmmmmph mmmmmmmph ggggggmmmmph!"

Brooke rolled around on the floor in the hogtie that Grace and Baleigh had placed her in. They'd used tape on her wrists and ankles in order to be quick and efficient, but with some of the leftover rope they had pulled her legs up to her wrists and hogtied her so that there was much less of a chance she'd get free. In her struggling, both of her black heels had slipped off leaving her feet bare in her patterned tights. To prevent her from calling out to Natalie and warning her, Grace had grabbed handfuls of dirty gym socks out of her laundry hamper and stuffed a good number inside Brooke's mouth before wrapping her face with tape.

"Ffffmmmmmph!"

Seeing Baleigh and Grace approach with Natalie in hand renewed Brooke's efforts as she thrashed around in her hogtie grunting and moaning through a mouth full of socks.

Baleigh and Grace lowered Natalie to the ground and shoving her onto her stomach, they pulled her legs up to meet her wrists and hogtied her as well.

"How the hell did you get free?!"

"You think this is our first rodeo?" Grace asked while pulling the last knot tight.

"This isn't fair!" Natalie pouted, "this was supposed to be our night of fun!"

"Cry about it," said Grace as she reached over to the pile of ankle socks she had grabbed from upstairs.

"We'll get back at you, just you wait and semmmmmmph!"

Grace took the opportunity to shove a bundle of her dirty socks into Natalie's open mouth making sure to pack them in as far as they'd go.

"Ggggnnnnnnmmmmmmppphhhh!"

Natalie moaned as Grace packed the wad of socks in, her mouth stuffed to the brim. A various assortment of colorful socks were peeking out now between her lips, her speech now totally cut off thanks to the cotton socks plugging her trap.

"Mmmmmmmmm gggggmmmmmmmph!"

She hollered through her stuffed mouth, but the socks were doing their job very well.

"Baleigh, if you wouldn't mind doing the honors."

"You got it!"

With the roll of tape in hand, Baleigh wrapped a few layers around Natalie's face to complete the gag. She and Baleigh then stepped back and watched as both girls writhed on the floor gently mewing through their sock stuffed faces.

"I don't know about you, Baleigh, but I think we should have a little fun before we call the police to come down and collect our friends, don't you think?"

"Hmmmmmmmph?!"

"Oh, I think you're absolutely right!"

Kneeling down next to Brooke, Grace reached out toward her exposed nylon clad feet before launching an all out tickle assault on them.

"GGGGGNNMPH!"

Brooke yelped and squealed as she tried to shake free from Grace, but her bindings held fast giving Grace complete and unhindered access to her feet. Tears poured down Brooke's face as her feet were relentlessly tickled. Hell, even Grace couldn't help but chuckle a bit.

Natalie was being given the same treatment by Baleigh who had tossed aside her red strappy heels before tickling her nylon clad feet too. Together, Brooke and Natalie squirmed on the floor, buckets of tears falling from their eyes, as Baleigh and Grace tickled them almost nonstop until the cops arrived.

The night had started off with a nasty trick, and Grace was still incensed at the fact that her carpet upstairs was now ruined, but at least it had all ended with a real treat.

Happy Halloween everyone!